There’s nothing fairly like a traditional grilled cheese sandwich with golden, buttery toasted bread and loads of gooey melted cheese within the center. Simply the thought is sufficient to get me salivating. It’s easy, nostalgic, and ridiculously scrumptious, however there are a number of little methods that make the distinction between an okay grilled cheese and a very good one.
Pair with a bowl of home made Tomato Basil Soup or our Caprese Soup.
Why My Recipe
- Just a little garlic powder and scorching sauce blended proper into the butter provides you a serious taste improve with out complicating issues.
- Cooking over medium-low warmth provides the cheese time to get completely melty whereas the bread slowly turns golden and crisp.
- Straightforward to customise with totally different breads, cheeses, and add-ins.


I’ve eaten lots of grilled cheese sandwiches in my life, and the key is persistence. It’s tempting to crank up the warmth so you may get to that crispy, tacky goodness quicker, however that’s how you find yourself with darkish bread and cheese that’s nonetheless barely melted within the center.
Medium-low warmth is the place the magic occurs. It provides the bread time to slowly toast in all that buttery goodness whereas the cheese will get good and gooey. And since I can by no means depart nicely sufficient alone, I combine just a little garlic powder and scorching sauce into the butter. It’s a tiny addition that makes a fundamental grilled cheese so a lot better.
Ingredient Notes


- Sandwich Bread: Common white sandwich bread provides you that traditional grilled cheese expertise, however sourdough might be my private favourite. Texas toast and brioche are additionally scrumptious in order for you one thing just a little extra substantial.
- Cheddar Cheese: Medium or sharp cheddar provides you loads of taste and melts superbly. Slices make meeting ridiculously simple, however freshly shredded cheddar works too.
- Butter: Be certain your butter is softened so you may unfold all of it the way in which to the sides of the bread with out tearing it.
- Garlic Powder: Just a bit bit blended into the butter provides the toasted bread an additional layer of taste with out overpowering the cheese.
- Scorching Sauce: One little sprint provides taste greater than warmth. Tabasco is my go-to right here, however you need to use no matter scorching sauce you may have available or depart it out totally.
The Secret to Completely Melted Cheese
The largest mistake individuals make with grilled cheese is utilizing an excessive amount of warmth. You need your skillet over medium-low warmth so the bread has loads of time to toast whereas the cheese melts.
In case your bread is getting brown earlier than the cheese is melted, flip the warmth down. You may also cowl the skillet with a lid for a minute or two. That traps just a little warmth inside and helps soften the cheese with out having to crank up the burner.
And don’t stroll away! As soon as that bread begins browning, issues can transfer fairly shortly.
Cheese Choices
Cheddar is the traditional for a cause, however there are such a lot of cheeses that make a superb grilled cheese. The hot button is selecting one thing that melts nicely.
Strive provolone, Monterey Jack, pepper jack, gouda, mozzarella, Havarti, Swiss, or American cheese. You may also mix cheeses. I like pairing a flavorful cheese like sharp cheddar with one thing further melty like Monterey Jack or American.


Combine it Up!
A grilled cheese is mainly a clean canvas for all types of scrumptious additions. Simply keep in mind that something you add must be comparatively dry so that you don’t find yourself with soggy bread.
Meat: Bacon and ham are classics. Be certain bacon is totally cooked earlier than including it to your sandwich. Thinly sliced leftover hen or turkey works too.
Veggies: Sautéed onions and mushrooms are unbelievable. Tomatoes and pickles work too, however pat them dry first and sandwich them between the cheese slices to assist maintain moisture away from the bread.
Spice it Up! Add purple pepper flakes, an additional drizzle of scorching sauce, or a number of jalapeño slices. Pickled jalapeños offer you a tangy little kick, whereas recent jalapeños add some crunch.
Bread Choices
You can also make grilled cheese with nearly any bread, however totally different breads provides you with a very totally different sandwich.
White Bread: The traditional. It will get crisp and golden on the skin whereas staying smooth inside.
Entire Wheat Bread: Provides your sandwich a nuttier taste and barely heartier texture.
Brioche: Comfortable, buttery, and just a bit candy.
Ciabatta: Crusty and chewy with loads of texture. Preserve the warmth low for the reason that thicker bread will take longer to heat by.
Texas Toast: Thick, smooth, and durable sufficient to deal with loads of cheese and add-ins.
Sourdough Bread: Certainly one of my private favorites! You get that crunchy, chewy texture with simply sufficient tang to steadiness all that buttery cheese.
Storage & Reheating
Grilled cheese is certainly greatest eaten scorching and recent from the skillet, however leftovers can nonetheless be saved.
Refrigerate in an hermetic container for as much as 3 days.
Reheat in a skillet over medium-low warmth for a couple of minutes per aspect till the bread crisps again up and the cheese is melted.
Reheat in an air fryer at 350°F for two to 4 minutes if you happen to occur to have one. It really works very well for bringing again that crispy exterior.
Extra air fryer recipes…
Trending Merchandise
